Hey, Trader Joe’s fans! With your love for TJ’s deals and quality finds, I’m thrilled to share a curated guide to 15 of Trader Joe’s most talked-about steaks, ranked from worst to best.
Whether you’re grilling for a family dinner or meal prepping, this list includes estimated prices (based on August 2025 data, varying by location), real fan feedback, taste test insights, and a rating out of 5 to help you choose the perfect steak.
Let’s dive into the ultimate TJ’s steak ranking!
15. Grass-Fed Ribeye
-
Price: ~$14.99 for 10 oz ($23.98/lb)
-
Reddit Feedback: “Looks kinda sad—go to a butcher instead,” one user said, citing lack of fat.
-
Taste Test Notes: Very lean with minimal marbling, leading to a dry texture. Beefy but lacks richness compared to conventional ribeye. Best for specific diets but underwhelming for steak lovers.
-
Rating: 2/5
14. Organic Grass-Fed Ribeye
-
Price: ~$14.99 for 10 oz ($23.98/lb)
-
Reddit Feedback: “No fat, super dry—Costco or a butcher is better,” a fan noted.
-
Taste Test Notes: Strong beefy flavor but lacks marbling, making it tough and dry. Good for health-conscious eaters but not ideal for indulgent steak nights.
-
Rating: 2.5/5
13. Steak & Stout Pies
-
Price: ~$6.99 for 2 pies (9 oz each)
-
Reddit Feedback: “Flavor’s good, but only 3 bits of tough meat—disappointing,” one user complained.
-
Taste Test Notes: Flaky crust with tasty filling, but the beef is inconsistent and often grisly. More about the pie than the steak, limiting its appeal.
-
Rating: 3/5
12. Sesame Teriyaki Beef Skirt Steak
-
Price: ~$21 for 1.33 lb ($16.99/lb)
-
Reddit Feedback: “Marinated meats are too salty and pricey,” one user said.
-
Taste Test Notes: USDA Choice Angus with a caramelized char, but the marinade is sour and overpowering. Tender when grilled, but better with a fresh marinade.
-
Rating: 3/5
11. Flank Steak
-
Price: ~$14.99 for 1 lb
-
Reddit Feedback: “Good flavor but chewy—use for stir-fry or nachos,” a fan suggested.
-
Taste Test Notes: Offers a crispy exterior and juicy interior, but its chewiness makes it better for recipes (like tacos) than standalone grilling.
-
Rating: 3.5/5
10. USDA Choice Angus Beef Flank Steak
-
Price: ~$14.99 for 1 lb
-
Reddit Feedback: “Tough but flavorful—great for recipes,” one user noted.
-
Taste Test Notes: Neutral flavor with juiciness when marinated and sliced thin. Ideal for dishes like fajitas but not a top standalone cut.
-
Rating: 3.5/5
9. Top Sirloin
-
Price: ~$8.99 for 8 oz
-
Reddit Feedback: “Needs sauce—affordable but kinda bland,” a fan commented.
-
Taste Test Notes: Vibrant red color with a crispy exterior, but the flavor is neutral. Elevate with sauces like Worcestershire or chimichurri for better results.
-
Rating: 3.5/5
8. Ribeye
-
Price: ~$15.99 for 1 Lb
-
Reddit Feedback: “Thinner and pricey—Costco’s ribeye is better value,” one user said.
-
Taste Test Notes: Tasty with a buttery quality, but thin cuts and less marbling require careful cooking. Some fatty bits need trimming.
-
Rating: 4/5
7. Argentinian Ribeye
-
Price: ~$16.39 for 12.6 oz ($19.99/lb)
-
Reddit Feedback: “Not as rich as U.S. ribeye—decent but not amazing,” a fan noted.
-
Taste Test Notes: Lighter, milder flavor than domestic ribeye, with thinner cuts but pleasant natural notes. Good for lighter meals.
-
Rating: 4/5
6. Choice Ribeye
-
Price: ~$16.39 for 12.6 oz ($19.99/lb)
-
Reddit Feedback: “Good marbling for Choice—pricey but solid,” one user said.
-
Taste Test Notes: Potent, buttery flavor with decent chew. Thinner than premium cuts but less fat to trim, making it user-friendly.
-
Rating: 4/5
5. Shaved Beef Steak
-
Price: ~$10.99 for 1 lb
-
Reddit Feedback: “Perfect for Philly cheesesteaks or tacos—cheap and versatile,” a fan raved.
-
Taste Test Notes: Derived from ribeye, this tender cut has rich flavor. Ideal for sandwiches, stir-fries, or pho, offering great value.
-
Rating: 4.5/5
4. Balsamic Rosemary Beef Steak Tips
-
Price: ~$11.99 for 1 lb
-
Reddit Feedback: “Convenient and tasty—nice crust,” one user said.
-
Taste Test Notes: Pre-marinated for tenderness with savory rosemary notes. Versatile for grilling, salads, or skewers, with a flavorful crust.
-
Rating: 4.5/5
3. New York Strip Steak
-
Price: ~$14.99 for 1 Lb
-
Reddit Feedback: “Buttery and zesty—half the price of restaurants,” a fan praised.
-
Taste Test Notes: Deep red color with a crunchy crust; buttery, zesty flavor and easy to chew. Delivers restaurant-quality taste at home.
-
Rating: 4.5/5
2. Choice New York Strip
-
Price: ~$13.99 for 10 oz
-
Reddit Feedback: “Thick and marbled—awesome value,” one user raved.
-
Taste Test Notes: Zesty, buttery, and thicker than other TJ’s strips. Easy to cook, perfect with frites or as a standalone steak.
-
Rating: 4.5/5
1. Filet Mignon
-
Price: ~$21.99 for 1 Lb
-
Reddit Feedback: “Restaurant-quality—super tender and flavorful,” a fan gushed.
-
Taste Test Notes: High marbling delivers a buttery, salty taste with a silky texture. Best for indulgent meals, cooks well medium-rare.
-
Rating: 5/5
