Hey, fellow Trader Joe’s enthusiasts! If you’re anything like me, wandering the cheese aisle at TJ’s feels like a treasure hunt—affordable gems, quirky flavors, and enough variety to build the ultimate charcuterie board.
I dove deep into expert reviews from top food sites and scoured Reddit for real fan feedback.
Drawing from taste tests highlighting nutty crunches, creamy melts, and bold kicks, plus raving (and honest) Redditor takes,
I’ve ranked 20 standout cheeses from “OK” (solid but skippable for some) to “Best” (must-buy legends). Prices are pulled where available (note: they can vary by location and time—current as of sources).
Let’s slice into it!
Blue Stilton Cheese
-
Price: $11.99/1 Lb
-
Taste Test: Tangy, acidic, funky, crumbly with a sour aftertaste
-
Fan Feedback: “Pretty damn good” on toasted baguettes, not the best Roquefort alternative
-
Recommend: No, only for intense blue cheese lovers
White Stilton with Apricots
-
Price: $11.99/1 Lb
-
Taste Test: Crumbly, cloyingly sweet, fruit-forward, almost artificial
-
Fan Feedback: Rarely mentioned, good with breakfast pastries or jam
-
Recommend: No, too sweet for purists
Cambozola Triple Cream Soft Ripened Cheese
-
Price: $13.99/1 Lb
-
Taste Test: Nutty, creamy, crumbly with blue veins, slightly artificial
-
Fan Feedback: “Bleu-veined brie must-have” with spicy honey
-
Recommend: No, underdelivers for the price
Burrata
-
Price: $4.99/8 Oz
-
Taste Test: Silky, mild, bland, creamy but messy
-
Fan Feedback: Affordable but needs flavor boost, good for caprese
-
Recommend: No, better as a base than a star
Mini Basque Cheese
-
Price: $13.99/1 Lb
-
Taste Test: Soft, muted tanginess, mild cheddar-brie mix
-
Fan Feedback: Easily overlooked, pair with chocolate or nuts
-
Recommend: No, too forgettable
Société Roquefort 1863
-
Price: $12/1 Lb
-
Taste Test: Funky, salty, nutty, super-crumbly with blue-green spots
-
Fan Feedback: “Delicious” and affordable, not elite
-
Recommend: Yes, for funky cheese adventurers
Fresh Mozzarella Cheese Pearls
-
Price: $4.49/8 Oz
-
Taste Test: Mild, neutral, perfect for skewers or caprese
-
Fan Feedback: Good for marinating, not a standalone star
-
Recommend: Yes, for versatile pairing
Everything But the Bagel Cheddar Cheese
-
Price: $4.99/8 Oz
-
Taste Test: Tangy, peppery, garlic-onion-sesame kick
-
Fan Feedback: “Versatile for boards,” some find it gimmicky
-
Recommend: Yes, great for dips or fondue
Double Cream Brie
-
Price: $4.49/8 Oz
-
Taste Test: Ultra-creamy, smooth, rich for baking or melting
-
Fan Feedback: “Always a crowd-pleaser”
-
Recommend: Yes, reliable for parties
Chèvre with Fine Herbs
-
Price: $3.29/5 Oz
-
Taste Test: Soft, tangy, herby with parsley, basil, dill
-
Fan Feedback: “Great with crackers,” not for goat skeptics
-
Recommend: Yes, for spreadable versatility
Dutch Smoked Cheese
-
Price: Not listed
-
Taste Test: Nutty, creamy, robust smoky gouda-style
-
Fan Feedback: Loved by smoky cheese fans, pairs with salami preview
-
Recommend: Yes, bold for boards
Délice de Bourgogne Triple Cream
-
Price: $5.49/5 oz
-
Taste Test: Buttery, mushroom-y, whipped texture
-
Fan Feedback: “Most affordable” triple cream, a fan favorite
-
Recommend: Yes, for creamy bliss
Chevre With Honey
-
Price: $3.29/5 Oz
-
Taste Test: Tangy goat cheese with sweet honey balance
-
Fan Feedback: “Customer favorite” for crackers or boards
-
Recommend: Yes, perfect sweet-tangy combo
Cranberry Chèvre Goat Cheese
-
Price: $5.99/8 Oz
-
Taste Test: Salty-sweet, perfect consistency, holiday vibe
-
Fan Feedback: Loved for springtime or with Ritz crackers
-
Recommend: Yes, seasonal hit
Baked Lemon Ricotta
-
Price: $13.99/1 Lb
-
Taste Test: Cheesecake-like, great with berries or graham crackers
-
Fan Feedback: “Party vanish-act,” eaten by the spoonful
-
Recommend: Yes, dessert-like delight
Italian Truffle Cheese
-
Price: $13.99/1 Lb
-
Taste Test: Musky, earthy, mild with truffle pieces
-
Fan Feedback: “Amazing for a decade,” great for eggs or boards
-
Recommend: Yes, umami powerhouse
Manchego Cheese
-
Price: $13.99/lb
-
Taste Test: Sharp, salty, nutty, buttery sheep’s milk
-
Fan Feedback: Affordable staple, great with meats
-
Recommend: Yes, excellent value
Cheddar with Caramelized Onions
-
Price: $10.99/1 Lb
-
Taste Test: Creamy, onion-forward, like French onion soup
-
Fan Feedback: “Superb,” “top tier” for burgers or grilled cheese
-
Recommend: Yes, savory star
Unexpected Cheddar Cheese
-
Price: $3.99/7 Oz
-
Taste Test: Crumbly cheddar-Parmesan mix, sharp, tangy with salt crystals
-
Fan Feedback: “Always a hit,” crowd-pleaser for snacks
-
Recommend: Yes, iconic hybrid
Creamy Toscano Cheese Soaked in Syrah
-
Price: $4.99/7.5 Oz
-
Taste Test: Creamy, nutty, Parmesan-cheddar with wine-soaked depth
-
Fan Feedback: “So flavorful, complex on its own”
-
Recommend: Yes, cheeseboard royalty
