Trader Joe’s is a haven for salsa lovers, offering a diverse lineup of jarred salsas that cater to every palate, from classic tomato to inventive fruit-based varieties. For TJ’s fans, we’ve compiled a taste test of 20 Trader Joe’s salsas.
Each salsa was evaluated for flavor, texture, heat level, and versatility, with a clear buy-or-skip ranking to guide your next Taco Tuesday or chip-dipping session. Below, we first list the salsas to skip, followed by those worth adding to your cart, ensuring TJ’s enthusiasts can navigate the salsa aisle with confidence.
These salsas fall short due to unbalanced flavors, lackluster heat, or poor texture, making them less worthy of your grocery budget.
Salsa Verde
Taste Test
- Expected to deliver a tangy, chile-forward kick, this green salsa disappoints with an overly salty profile and minimal tomatillo or spice presence. It lacks the vibrancy of a true salsa verde, tasting flat despite its appealing color. At ~$2.29, it’s not worth the jar space.
Ranking: Skip
-
Too salty and underwhelming for a green salsa.
Pineapple Salsa
Taste Test
- This salsa aims for a sweet-tropical vibe but ends up cloyingly sweet, masking any promised spice. The pineapple flavor overpowers, making it taste more like a dessert topping than a salsa, unsuitable for chips or savory dishes.
Ranking: Skip
-
Sickeningly sweet and unbalanced.
Spicy, Smoky, Peach Salsa
Taste Test
- While the chunky peach pieces provide great texture, the flavor is described as “meh” and lacks excitement. The promised smokiness and spice are barely noticeable, and the tomato base overpowers the peach. At ~$2.29, it’s a pass unless mixed with another salsa like Salsa Autentica.
Ranking: Skip
- Unremarkable and needs tweaking to shine.
Fat Free Chunky Salsa
Taste Test
- Marketed as low-medium heat, this salsa is overly sweet and very mild, with minimal spice to balance the tomato-heavy flavor. While it’s fine for sensitive palates, it lacks depth and feels generic despite its fat-free claim (most salsas are low-calorie anyway).
Ranking: Skip
- Too mild and sweet, not memorable.
Salsa Especial (Medium)
Taste Test
- This salsa promises a medium heat but delivers a mild, overly sweet flavor with a watery texture. The tomato and pepper blend lacks complexity, making it a forgettable choice for dipping or cooking.
Ranking: Skip
- Lacks the punch and texture expected from a medium salsa.
Garlic Chipotle Salsa
Taste Test
- Despite its enticing name, this salsa underdelivers with a muted garlic and chipotle presence. The flavor is flat, and the heat is barely noticeable, making it a disappointing choice for chipotle fans. At ~$2.49, it’s not worth the hype.
Ranking: Skip
- Fails to deliver bold garlic or chipotle flavors.
Salsa de Casa
Taste Test
- This restaurant-style salsa is thin and lacks the chunkiness or bold seasoning needed to stand out. It’s overly simplistic, with a tomato-heavy taste that doesn’t excite, even at a budget-friendly price.
Ranking: Skip
- Too basic and uninspiring for TJ’s standards.
Cowboy Caviar
Taste Test
- A vibrant mix of corn, black beans, peppers, and adobo sauce, this salsa offers a rustic, slightly sweet flavor with a fun, chunky texture. While a touch sweet for some, its unique profile makes it a versatile dip or topping for tacos and salads. At ~$2.99, it’s a fan favorite.
Ranking: Buy
- Flavorful and fun, perfect for Tex-Mex lovers.
Pepita Salsa
Taste Test
- Roasted pumpkin seeds add a nutty depth to this tomato-based salsa, blended with onion and bell pepper for a rich, cohesive flavor. It’s surprisingly delicious and versatile, ideal for dipping or as a marinade for pork chops. Priced at ~$2.99, it’s a unique gem.
Ranking: Buy
- A tasty, unexpected winner with great texture.
Organic Thick & Chunky Salsa
Taste Test
- This salsa delivers a deep, spicy tomato flavor with a rustic, chunky texture that’s more cohesive than pico de gallo. It’s significantly spicier than TJ’s milder options, earning high marks for flavor and value at ~$2.99.
Ranking: Buy
- One of the best red salsas for spice lovers.
Salsa Autentica
Taste Test
- A classic restaurant-style salsa with a balanced blend of sweet tomato, garlic, onion, salt, and yellow chili pepper. It’s mild (despite a “high medium” label) but versatile, perfect for chips or Mexican dishes. At ~$2.29, it’s a budget-friendly staple.
Ranking: Buy
- Reliable and delicious for everyday use.
Organic Tomatillo & Roasted Yellow Chili Salsa
Taste Test
- This green salsa offers a complex, garlicky flavor with chipotle peppers, delivering a mild heat that satisfies. It’s a group favorite for its bold taste and versatility, perfect for chips or cooking, at ~$2.49 for a 16-ounce jar.
Ranking: Buy
- A flavorful green salsa with great value.
Hatch Valley Salsa
Taste Test
- Featuring roasted Hatch chiles, this salsa brings Southwestern flair with a smoky, medium-spicy kick. It’s ideal for dipping or slow-cooking with pork shoulder, offering a rich, layered flavor. Note: It may be discontinued, but available on Amazon for ~$18 (2-pack).
Ranking: Buy
- A must for chile lovers, if you can find it.
Double Roasted Salsa
Taste Test
- The double-roasted tomatoes and peppers create a smoky, robust flavor with a medium heat level. Its thick texture makes it great for dipping or as a base for chili. Shoppers praise its depth at ~$2.99.
Ranking: Buy
- A smoky, versatile option for bold palates.
Chunky Salsa
Taste Test
- This non-fat-free version offers a chunkier texture than Salsa Autentica, with a balanced tomato and pepper flavor. It’s mildly spicy but delivers on taste, making it a solid choice for dipping or tacos at ~$2.29.
Ranking: Buy
- A classic, crowd-pleasing salsa.
Roasted Tomatillo Salsa
Taste Test
- A tangier take on salsa verde, this option balances tomatillo tartness with a mild chili kick. It’s great for enchiladas or as a marinade, with a fresh, vibrant flavor at ~$2.49.
Ranking: Buy
- A solid green salsa for Mexican dishes.
Spicy Chunky Tomato & Pepper Salsa
Taste Test
- This salsa amps up the heat with a chunky texture and bold tomato-pepper blend. It’s a step above Salsa Autentica for spice lovers, offering versatility for dipping or cooking at ~$2.99.
Ranking: Buy
- Great for those who want a spicier kick.
Fire Roasted Tomato Salsa
Taste Test
- The fire-roasted tomatoes give this salsa a smoky, slightly sweet flavor with medium heat. It’s thick and ideal for chips or as a topping for grilled meats, earning praise at ~$2.49.
Ranking: Buy
- A smoky, flavorful choice for roasting fans.
Salsa de Chile Fresco
Taste Test
- This fresh-chile salsa offers a bright, spicy flavor with a smooth texture, perfect for those who prefer a less chunky dip. It’s versatile for tacos or nachos, with a solid heat level at ~$2.99.
Ranking: Buy
- A fresh, spicy option for purists.
Corn & Chile Tomato-Less Salsa
Taste Test
- A unique tomato-less salsa with sweet corn, red bell peppers, and a mild heat. It’s more of a dip than a traditional salsa, perfect for pairing with tortilla chips or as a salad topping. At ~$2.99, it’s a fun, versatile pick.
Ranking: Buy
- A creative, flavorful alternative for variety seekers.
Note: Prices and availability vary by location. Always check your local Trader Joe’s for stock, and consider expiration dates for freshness. For discontinued items like Hatch Valley Salsa, check online retailers like Amazon.
