Trader Joe’s Pumpkin Products Reviewed: Buy or Skip?

Trader Joe’s pumpkin season is no joke. From breakfast pastries and cookies to pasta, ice cream, and even skincare, the store has found a way to put pumpkin into almost everything. But after comparing extensive taste tests with real shopper reviews, one thing becomes clear: not every pumpkin product deserves a spot in your cart.

Pumpkin Breakfast & Bakery Finds

1. Pumpkin Streusel Muffins — $5.99

Pumpkin Streusel Muffins at Trader Joe's

Verdict: BUY — One of the best pumpkin products

These gluten-free muffins are surprisingly fluffy, moist, and packed with genuine pumpkin flavor. The cinnamon-streusel topping provides a buttery crunch without overwhelming the soft cake underneath.

Even shoppers who normally avoid gluten-free baked goods have been impressed. They’re sweet enough to pass for dessert, but alongside a strong cup of coffee, they make an excellent fall breakfast. Easily one of the most reliable buys in the entire lineup.

2. Pumpkin Loaf — $5.49

Pumpkin Loaf at Trader Joe's

Verdict: TRY ONCE — Good, but not outstanding

There’s a nice pumpkin flavor running through this ready-made loaf, with warm spices and a lightly sugary crust. The texture is fairly moist, although some tasters notice an unusual aftertaste that keeps it from feeling truly homemade.

It’s convenient when you don’t want to bake, but the Pumpkin Streusel Muffins offer a more interesting texture. Toasting a thick slice with butter helps considerably.

3. Pumpkin Bagels — $2.99

Pumpkin Bagels at Trader Joe's

Verdict: TRY ONCE — Better toasted

The pumpkin flavor is pleasant but subtle, while the texture leans closer to soft packaged bread than a chewy bakery-style bagel.

Some shoppers enjoy them with pumpkin cream cheese or cinnamon butter, but others have complained that the 2026 version seems particularly doughy. They’re fine for a quick seasonal breakfast, just don’t expect an authentic bagel-shop experience.

4. Pumpkin Biscotti — $4.99

Pumpkin Biscotti at Trader Joe's

Verdict: BUY — Especially for coffee drinkers

These crunchy cookies deliver plenty of cinnamon, ginger, and pumpkin spice. They’re slightly sweeter and more crumbly than traditional biscotti, which may disappoint anyone who prefers a firmer, less sugary cookie.

However, the texture becomes much more enjoyable when dunked into hot coffee. The spices are strong enough to stand up to espresso, making these a worthwhile seasonal treat for anyone who loves a morning coffee ritual.

5. Pumpkin Brioche Twist — $4.99

Pumpkin Brioche Twist at Trader Joe's

Verdict: BUY — Excellent for French toast

This thick, twisted loaf has a buttery flavor with gentle pumpkin spice running throughout. Straight from the package, it can seem a little drier than expected, but a quick toast transforms it.

Its biggest selling point is versatility. Shoppers have turned it into French toast, bread pudding, and buttery breakfast slices. Letting the bread dry slightly before making French toast helps it absorb the custard without falling apart.

6. Sliced Pumpkin Sourdough Bread — $4.99

Sliced Pumpkin Sourdough Bread at Trader Joe's

Verdict: BUY — One of 2026’s most interesting arrivals

This newcomer has been getting plenty of attention because it’s not another sugary pumpkin cake pretending to be bread.

It offers a mild pumpkin sweetness, warm spices, and a subtle sourdough tang. Opinions on the texture vary, but toasted slices have won over many shoppers. It works surprisingly well with salted butter, cream cheese, sharp cheddar, or even as the base for French toast.

7. Greek Nonfat Pumpkin Yogurt — $0.99

Greek Nonfat Pumpkin Yogurt at Trader Joe's

Verdict: SKIP — The flavors don’t quite work

Combining tart Greek yogurt with pumpkin pie spice sounds appealing, but the resulting flavor can be rather strange.

The tanginess competes with the cinnamon, cloves, and pumpkin instead of complementing them. Despite its sweetness, the yogurt still has a sharp finish that some tasters describe as artificial. Plain Greek yogurt with a spoonful of pumpkin butter may be a better option.

8. Pumpkin Oat Bites — $3.99

Pumpkin Oat Bites at Trader Joe's

Verdict: TRY ONCE — Very texture-dependent

These tiny oat-based snacks have a soft pumpkin filling surrounded by a dense, chewy exterior.

Some shoppers appreciate the convenient size and balanced spices. Others find them excessively thick, almost pasty, especially when eating more than one. They also pack a surprising amount of sugar into a small bite.

They’re convenient for lunchboxes or an afternoon snack, but not necessarily something everyone will want to stockpile.

9. Pumpkin O’s Cereal — $3.49

Pumpkin O's Cereal at Trader Joe's

Verdict: SKIP — A disappointing seasonal cereal

The pumpkin and cinnamon flavors are relatively mild, and the cereal can taste more like lightly sweetened O’s than a genuinely pumpkin-flavored breakfast.

Several longtime shoppers also complained that the 2026 version seemed different from the cereal they remembered, particularly in texture and sweetness. Milk helps soften the flavor, but there are more memorable breakfast options available.

10. Pumpkin Spice Cream Cheese Spread — $2.79

Pumpkin Spice Cream Cheese Spread at Trader Joe's

Verdict: BUY — One of the most useful fall spreads

Trader Joe’s introduced a new supplier for its 2026 version, which combines tangy cream cheese with pumpkin, brown sugar, cinnamon, and nutmeg.

It’s smooth, easy to spread, and sweet without feeling like frosting. The flavor works beautifully on toasted bagels, brioche, or cinnamon-raisin bread.

It also has dessert potential. A little added to cheesecake filling or frosting brings an easy pumpkin-spice twist without requiring much preparation.

11. Frozen Pumpkin Waffles — $2.99

Frozen Pumpkin Waffles at Trader Joe's

Verdict: SKIP — Convenient but forgettable

These frozen waffles have received mixed reactions. Some tasters appreciate the light crispness after toasting, but others find them dry, crumbly, and surprisingly bland.

The pumpkin flavor isn’t particularly noticeable, and a slightly bitter finish has been reported. Maple syrup helps, but the Pumpkin Pancake & Waffle Mix produces a much more satisfying breakfast if you’re willing to spend a few extra minutes cooking.

12. Pumpkin Pancake & Waffle Mix — $3.99

Pumpkin Pancake & Waffle Mix at Trader Joe's

Verdict: BUY — A standout seasonal baking mix

This is one of the strongest breakfast products in the entire pumpkin collection.

The pancakes cook up fluffy with lightly crisp edges and a pleasantly balanced pumpkin-spice flavor. They taste especially good with real maple syrup and butter, without needing excessive toppings.

It’s also a convenient option for homemade waffles, and shoppers have reported freezing leftovers successfully. A reliable seasonal pantry purchase.

13. Pumpkin & Spice Brioche-Style Liège Waffles — $4.49

Pumpkin & Spice Brioche-Style Liège Waffles at Trader Joe's

Verdict: SKIP — Too sweet for the payoff

These individually portioned waffles are much sweeter than ordinary breakfast waffles, with chunks of sugar throughout the dough.

Heating improves their texture, but the sweetness can become overwhelming, and some tasters detect an odd, slightly artificial flavor underneath the spices.

They work better as a dessert-style pastry than a traditional waffle, but there are far better pumpkin treats available.

14. Pumpkin Bread & Muffin Mix — $3.49

Pumpkin Bread & Muffin Mix at Trader Joe's

Verdict: BUY — A dependable fall baking shortcut

This boxed mix has earned praise for its easy preparation and familiar pumpkin-bread flavor.

It produces a dense, warmly spiced loaf, although the finished texture can vary depending on baking time and added ingredients. Some tasters find the plain version a little heavy or nutmeg-forward.

For better results, try baking it as muffins or adding chocolate chips, chopped pecans, or a cream cheese swirl. It’s a particularly useful mix to keep around for unexpected guests.

15. Pumpkin Cream Cheese Croissants — $3.99

Pumpkin Cream Cheese Croissants at Trader Joe's

Verdict: TRY ONCE — Delicious when warmed

These new seasonal pastries feature a soft croissant-style exterior with pumpkin-spiced cream cheese filling.

The biggest criticism is that there simply isn’t enough filling. Some bites taste mostly like sweet bread, and the pastry lacks the flakiness of a bakery croissant.

A brief warming improves the texture and brings out the pumpkin flavor. Worth trying once, especially if you enjoy sweet breakfast pastries.

16. Mini Pumpkin Ginger Scones — $4.99

Mini Pumpkin Ginger Scones at Trader Joe's

Verdict: BUY — A welcome seasonal return

These small bake-at-home scones have become a favorite among shoppers who missed the product during previous seasons.

The pumpkin flavor is stronger than the ginger, so even people who aren’t enthusiastic about ginger may enjoy them. Baking gives the exterior a delicate crispness while keeping the inside tender.

Several shoppers recommend removing them from the oven slightly earlier than the maximum package time. They’re particularly good with coffee or a little pumpkin caramel sauce.

17. Glazed Pumpkin Pie Spice Donut Holes — $3.49

Glazed Pumpkin Pie Spice Donut Holes at Trader Joe's

Verdict: BUY — One of the season’s best sweet snacks

These gluten-free and dairy-free donut holes have been getting enthusiastic reviews for their soft texture and sweet pumpkin-spice flavor.

They resemble classic glazed bakery donut holes, with enough cinnamon and spice to distinguish them from ordinary glazed donuts.

Some tasters notice a slightly oily finish, and the package disappears quickly because the portions are small. Still, the flavor and texture make these a standout among the 2026 seasonal sweets.

18. Pecan Pumpkin Oatmeal — $3.79

Pecan Pumpkin Oatmeal at Trader Joe's

Verdict: BUY — A convenient autumn breakfast

This instant oatmeal combines real pecan pieces, pumpkin, and warm spices in a sweet breakfast bowl.

The pecans add a welcome nutty flavor that keeps the pumpkin spice from becoming monotonous. It leans toward a dessert-style oatmeal, but the oats provide enough substance for breakfast.

It’s particularly good with milk instead of water, plus a few extra pecans on top. An easy choice for busy mornings.

19. Pumpkin Overnight Oats — $1.99

Pumpkin Overnight Oats at Trader Joe's

Verdict: TRY ONCE — A healthier-tasting alternative

These refrigerated oats contain pumpkin puree, dates, almond butter, cinnamon, and nutmeg, with no added sugar.

The texture is thick and hearty rather than creamy and dessert-like. Some shoppers appreciate the natural sweetness, while others find the flavor flat and the oats too dense.

A few apple slices, extra cinnamon, or a splash of milk can make them more enjoyable. Good for convenience, but not a universal favorite.

20. This Pumpkin Walks Into a Bar Cereal Bars — $2.49

This Pumpkin Walks Into a Bar Cereal Bars at Trader Joe's

Verdict: BUY — A practical seasonal snack

These soft cereal bars are filled with a sweet pumpkin-flavored center and offer a familiar breakfast-bar texture.

The spices are relatively restrained, making them approachable even for people who aren’t obsessed with pumpkin spice.

They’re not a replacement for homemade pumpkin pastries, but they’re convenient for school lunches, travel bags, and quick afternoon snacks. Several longtime shoppers continue buying them every fall.

21. Pumpkin Spice Coffee — $9.99

Pumpkin Spice Coffee at Trader Joe's

Verdict: TRY ONCE — Best for spice lovers

Trader Joe’s seasonal ground coffee blends Arabica beans with cinnamon, nutmeg, allspice, orange peel, and vanilla.

Rather than a sweet coffeehouse pumpkin latte, expect a regular brewed coffee with noticeable aromatic spices. The orange peel gives it a slightly different character from most pumpkin coffees.

It’s worth trying if you enjoy flavored coffee, but people who prefer the clean taste of unflavored beans may find the spices distracting.

22. Organic Pumpkin Pie Spice Creamer — $2.99

Organic Pumpkin Pie Spice Creamer at Trader Joe's

Verdict: TRY ONCE — Better in small quantities

This seasonal creamer has generated mixed reactions. Some shoppers love its sweet cinnamon-forward flavor, while others find that the pumpkin itself barely comes through.

One recurring complaint is that the flavor seems strong when tasted alone but weakens considerably once mixed into coffee.

It performs better in lighter coffee or when frothed into a latte. Worth experimenting with, but not necessarily a replacement for your everyday creamer.

Pumpkin Cookies, Snacks & Spreads

23. Pumpkin Spice Tortilla Chips — $2.49

Pumpkin Spice Tortilla Chips at Trader Joe's

Verdict: TRY ONCE — Surprisingly subtle

These corn tortilla chips contain pumpkin and pumpkin pie spices, but they don’t taste nearly as unusual as the packaging suggests.

Initially, they’re mostly ordinary corn chips. A faint cinnamon-and-spice note develops afterward, creating a sweet-savory combination that divides opinions.

They pair reasonably well with fall salsa, although anyone expecting a bold pumpkin flavor may be disappointed. An interesting novelty rather than an essential repeat purchase.

24. Fall Harvest Salsa — $3.49

Fall Harvest Salsa at Trader Joe's

Verdict: BUY — Better than it sounds

Pumpkin, apples, and butternut squash might not sound like obvious salsa ingredients, but the combination works better than expected.

The salsa is slightly sweet and fruity, with enough savory character to keep it suitable for dipping. The pumpkin doesn’t dominate, which is probably a good thing.

Some tasters have found it surprisingly addictive, particularly with salty tortilla chips. It’s also a creative topping for grilled chicken or a fall-inspired taco night.

25. Pumpkin Spiced Teeny Tiny Pretzels — $3.49

Pumpkin Spiced Teeny Tiny Pretzels at Trader Joe's

Verdict: SKIP — Not enough pumpkin flavor

These miniature pretzels are covered in a sweet yogurt-flavored coating with bits of pumpkin-spiced seeds.

The sweet-and-salty combination should work, but several tasters find the flavor surprisingly ordinary. Some have also reported a stale-tasting finish.

They aren’t necessarily terrible, but they don’t deliver enough distinctive pumpkin spice to justify choosing them over regular yogurt-covered pretzels.

26. Pumpkin Spiced Pumpkin Seeds — $3.99

Pumpkin Spiced Pumpkin Seeds at Trader Joe's

Verdict: TRY ONCE — Good crunch, uneven results

These roasted pumpkin seeds have a crunchy, sweet spiced coating that gives them a candied quality.

Some shoppers love the combination of warm spices and toasted pepitas. Others find the coating too sweet, while one extensive taste test reported an unpleasant burnt flavor across multiple handfuls.

Batch variation may affect the experience. They’re worth trying if you enjoy candied nuts, but anyone expecting a salty roasted-seed snack should look elsewhere.

27. Petite Pumpkin Spice Cookies — $4.49

Petite Pumpkin Spice Cookies at Trader Joe's

Verdict: BUY — A charming fall cookie

These little decorated cookies are covered in yogurt-flavored icing and colorful sprinkles.

The base is crisp and more reminiscent of a spiced graham cracker than a buttery shortbread. The coating adds sweetness, while the little sprinkles provide extra crunch.

They’re admittedly sugary, but the pumpkin spice is pleasant and not overpowering. A fun cookie for fall snack trays or a seasonal treat with coffee.

28. Pumpkin-Flavored Joe-Joe’s — $2.99

Pumpkin-Flavored Joe-Joe's at Trader Joe's

Verdict: BUY — A reliable pumpkin cookie

Trader Joe’s seasonal sandwich cookies combine crisp spiced cookies with a sweet pumpkin-flavored filling.

The flavor is stronger than a plain vanilla sandwich cookie without becoming overly complicated. The cookies have a satisfying crunch, and the filling provides enough sweetness to balance the spices.

They’re particularly good with milk and have earned repeat purchases from shoppers who look forward to their return each fall.

29. Pumpkin-Spiced Joe-Joe’s Sandwich Cookies — $4.49

Pumpkin-Spiced Joe-Joe's Sandwich Cookies at Trader Joe's

Verdict: TRY ONCE — For serious pumpkin-spice fans

These take the regular pumpkin Joe-Joe’s and cover them in a pumpkin-spiced yogurt coating with sea salt.

That extra coating makes them richer, sweeter, and much more intense. Some tasters love the combination of crunchy cookies and creamy exterior, while others find the spice overwhelming.

If you love heavily coated sandwich cookies, there’s plenty to enjoy. For a more balanced pumpkin flavor, the regular Pumpkin Joe-Joe’s are the safer choice.

30. Pumpkin Blondie Brownies — $4.99

Pumpkin Blondie Brownies at Trader Joe's

Verdict: BUY — Much better than their name suggests

Despite the name, these are closer to soft pumpkin snack cakes than traditional chewy blondies.

The pumpkin flavor is relatively mild, and the white baking chips add little pockets of sweetness. Some tasters criticize the lack of brownie-like density, but many shoppers genuinely love the moist, cake-like texture.

Warming them slightly makes them even better. They’re a particularly good option with vanilla ice cream or a spoonful of whipped cream.

31. Pumpkin Butter — $2.99

Pumpkin Butter at Trader Joe's

Verdict: BUY — A fall pantry essential

This thick pumpkin spread delivers concentrated pumpkin flavor, sweetness, and warm spices.

It’s excellent on toast, muffins, pancakes, and waffles, but its usefulness extends well beyond breakfast. Shoppers have mixed it into yogurt, cream cheese, and even coffee drinks.

Its sweetness makes it less suitable for every savory application, but as a dessert spread it’s one of the most versatile seasonal products Trader Joe’s sells.

32. Pumpkin & Spice Caramel Sauce — $3.99

Pumpkin & Spice Caramel Sauce at Trader Joe's

Verdict: BUY — Best used as a dessert topping

This thick caramel sauce has become one of the more talked-about 2026 releases.

The texture is unusually dense and stretchy, with rich caramel sweetness and a background of pumpkin and warm spices. Some tasters detect an artificial finish, but many shoppers have been enthusiastic enough to return for multiple jars.

It’s especially good with apple slices, vanilla ice cream, and warm desserts. Mixing it into coffee can be difficult unless it’s warmed or thoroughly frothed.

33. Pumpkin Cranberry Crisps — $3.99

Pumpkin Cranberry Crisps at Trader Joe's

Verdict: BUY — Excellent for entertaining

These thin, crunchy crackers combine pumpkin, tart cranberry pieces, herbs, and warm spices.

The sweetness can seem a little unexpected when eaten alone, but the combination makes much more sense with cheese. Goat cheese, Brie, and cream cheese are especially good pairings.

They provide an easy way to make an ordinary cheese board feel seasonal without much extra work. One of the better savory-adjacent pumpkin products.

34. Pumpkin & Spice Snickerdoodle Cookie Mix — $3.99

Pumpkin & Spice Snickerdoodle Cookie Mix at Trader Joe's

Verdict: TRY ONCE — Familiar more than exciting

Snickerdoodles already feature cinnamon, so the added pumpkin flavor doesn’t dramatically change the finished cookie.

The baking mix produces sweet, softly spiced cookies, although texture reactions vary. Some tasters enjoy the tenderness, while others wish they had the familiar chew of a homemade snickerdoodle.

They’re convenient for fall baking, but not particularly distinctive. Adding your own cinnamon-sugar coating can give them a better finish.

35. Pumpkin Pie Spice Bark — $5.49

Pumpkin Pie Spice Bark at Trader Joe's

Verdict: SKIP — Too much going on

This candy combines pumpkin-spiced white chocolate with gingersnap pieces, pretzels, dark chocolate drizzle, and sea salt.

On paper, it sounds like an excellent sweet-and-salty dessert. In practice, the heavy white chocolate and strong spices often overwhelm everything else.

Multiple independent taste tests criticized the cloying sweetness and lack of balance. The interesting mix-ins aren’t enough to rescue it, making this one of the easier products to skip.

36. Pumpkin Caramel Kringle — $9.99

Pumpkin Caramel Kringle at Trader Joe's

Verdict: BUY — Best shared with family

This returning pastry from O&H Danish Bakery features a buttery, flaky ring filled with pumpkin and topped with sweet caramel icing and pecans.

The filling tastes like a cross between pumpkin pie and a cinnamon pastry. It’s rich, extremely sweet, and particularly enjoyable warmed slightly.

The main drawback is how quickly the sweetness becomes overwhelming. Cut it into smaller portions and serve with coffee. It also freezes well, making it convenient for holiday entertaining.

Savory Pumpkin Foods

37. Pumpkin Bisque — $5.49

Pumpkin Bisque at Trader Joe's

Verdict: SKIP — One of the weakest savory products

Trader Joe’s pumpkin bisque combines pumpkin puree, cream, honey, tahini, and apple cider vinegar.

Unfortunately, the combination doesn’t appeal to everyone. The vinegar adds noticeable acidity, while the tahini contributes an earthy nuttiness that can taste unpleasant alongside the sweetness.

The supplied taste test was especially harsh, and other diners have complained about the sour finish. There are much better pumpkin soups to make at home.

38. Honey Roasted Pumpkin Ravioli — $3.99

Honey Roasted Pumpkin Ravioli at Trader Joe's

Verdict: BUY — A seasonal dinner worth trying

These colorful ravioli have tender pasta surrounding a pumpkin-and-cheese filling with a noticeable honey sweetness.

Texture and flavor opinions differ. Some tasters find the filling overly dense, but others praise the combination when paired with the right sauce.

Brown butter, sage, Parmesan, and toasted walnuts make an excellent combination. Avoid overly sweet sauces, which can turn the dish into something closer to dessert than dinner.

39. Pumpkin Gnocchi — $3.29

Pumpkin Gnocchi at Trader Joe's

Verdict: BUY — A useful fall dinner shortcut

These refrigerated pumpkin gnocchi have a slightly sweet flavor and a soft, pleasantly chewy texture.

They don’t have the delicate lightness of homemade gnocchi, but they’re satisfying enough for a quick weeknight meal.

The sweetness works particularly well with savory sauces, browned butter, Parmesan, and herbs. Some shoppers have also enjoyed them with pesto or vodka sauce. A solid choice when you want something different from ordinary pasta.

40. Autumnal Harvest Creamy Pasta Sauce — $4.49

Autumnal Harvest Creamy Pasta Sauce at Trader Joe's

Verdict: TRY ONCE — More tomato than pumpkin

Despite its autumn-themed name, this sauce tastes predominantly like creamy tomato sauce.

Pumpkin and butternut squash contribute sweetness and body, but neither flavor stands out strongly. The result is a smooth, mildly sweet sauce that may disappoint anyone expecting a savory pumpkin puree.

It works well enough over pasta, especially with Parmesan or Italian sausage, but the seasonal branding is more interesting than the actual flavor.

41. Mini Spicy Pumpkin Samosas — $4.49

Mini Spicy Pumpkin Samosas at Trader Joe's

Verdict: BUY — One of the better savory surprises

These frozen mini samosas combine pumpkin, paneer cheese, and warming spices inside a crispy pastry shell.

Unlike many pumpkin products, these bring genuine heat. The spicy filling works nicely against the natural sweetness of the pumpkin, while the flaky wrapper provides a satisfying crunch.

They can still taste a little sweet on their own, so pairing them with mint chutney or another tangy dipping sauce makes them even better. A strong appetizer choice.

Pumpkin Cakes, Pies & Frozen Desserts

42. Pumpkin Spice Mini Sheet Cake — $5.99

Pumpkin Spice Mini Sheet Cake at Trader Joe's

Verdict: BUY — A clear shopper favorite

This little cake has built a loyal following, particularly among shoppers who love cream cheese frosting.

The pumpkin cake is soft and moist, while the thick frosting adds a rich, tangy sweetness. It’s not a fancy bakery dessert, but that’s part of its appeal.

Some people find the frosting excessive, yet many shoppers buy multiple cakes while they’re available. It freezes surprisingly well, too. One of the easiest seasonal desserts to recommend.

43. Pumpkin Flan — $3.49

Pumpkin Flan at Trader Joe's

Verdict: TRY ONCE — Extremely polarizing

This pumpkin-flavored custard looks appealing, with a smooth filling and a generous layer of caramel sauce.

The texture can be pleasant, but the flavor has divided reviewers. Some appreciate the subtle pumpkin spices, while others detect artificial vanilla notes, bitterness, or an unpleasant aftertaste in the caramel.

Traditional flan lovers may find it interesting, but it isn’t a safe choice for entertaining. Try a single package before considering more.

44. Pumpkin Cheesecake — $8.99

Pumpkin Cheesecake at Trader Joe's

Verdict: BUY — A much better holiday dessert than expected

This frozen cheesecake features a thick graham cracker crust and creamy pumpkin-spiced filling.

The texture is dense, and some tasters consider the pumpkin flavor a little artificial. However, other independent reviewers have been enthusiastic about its balance of cheesecake tanginess and autumn spices.

For a ready-made holiday dessert, it’s a convenient option that feels more substantial than a miniature sheet cake. Serve chilled with a little whipped cream.

45. Pumpkin Ice Cream — $4.99

Pumpkin Ice Cream at Trader Joe's

Verdict: SKIP — Too heavy on the spices

Trader Joe’s pumpkin ice cream has a creamy base with plenty of nutmeg, cloves, and other pumpkin-pie spices.

The trouble is that these spices can overwhelm the actual pumpkin flavor. Some shoppers compare it to eggnog, which may appeal to certain tastes, but several reviewers found it overly perfumed or medicinal.

If you love intensely spiced holiday desserts, you might enjoy it. Otherwise, regular vanilla ice cream with pumpkin butter is a safer bet.

46. Hold the Cone Pumpkin Ginger Ice Cream Cones — $3.99

Hold the Cone Pumpkin Ginger Ice Cream Cones at Trader Joe's

Verdict: TRY ONCE — Great concept, mixed execution

These miniature ice cream cones combine pumpkin-spiced ice cream, a ginger-flavored cone, and a sweet coating.

The ginger cone is arguably the best part. It adds a crunchy, spicy contrast that helps distinguish the dessert from ordinary pumpkin ice cream.

Some shoppers adore them, while others report an icy filling and an overly sweet coating. Worth trying for the novelty, but the texture may determine whether you purchase them again.

47. Teeny Tiny Pumpkin Pies — $5.49

Teeny Tiny Pumpkin Pies at Trader Joe's

Verdict: BUY — Perfectly portioned pumpkin desserts

These miniature pumpkin pies are ideal for shoppers who want a small seasonal dessert without committing to an entire pie.

The pumpkin filling is smooth and gently spiced, while the pastry provides a light crust. Opinions differ on how crisp that crust is straight from the package, but brief warming helps.

They’re convenient for individual desserts, small gatherings, or a Thanksgiving treat when nobody wants another large slice of pie.

Pumpkin Candles & Body Care

48. Vanilla Pumpkin Scented Candle — $3.99

Vanilla Pumpkin Scented Candle at Trader Joe's

Verdict: TRY ONCE — Best for strong cinnamon-scent lovers

Trader Joe’s brought this seasonal candle back with a replacement supplier, so the current version isn’t necessarily identical to older favorites.

The fragrance leans heavily toward cinnamon and warm baking spices, with vanilla softening the edges.

Some people enjoy that cozy holiday-shop scent, but others find it much closer to a cinnamon broom than freshly baked pumpkin pie. Smell it in person before committing.

49. Pumpkin Body Butter — $4.99

Pumpkin Body Butter at Trader Joe's

Verdict: TRY ONCE — Popular fragrance, rich texture

This seasonal body butter combines a pumpkin-spice fragrance with a thick, oil-rich moisturizing formula.

Its scent has loyal fans, and some shoppers purchase several containers to last beyond fall. However, the texture can feel greasy, especially when applied generously.

It’s best suited for people who enjoy heavily scented body products and prefer rich moisturizers. Anyone looking for something light and fast-absorbing may find it too heavy.

50. Pumpkin Ultra Moisturizing Hand Cream — $4.99

Pumpkin Ultra Moisturizing Hand Cream at Trader Joe's

Verdict: SKIP — The fragrance takes over

This pumpkin-themed hand cream delivers a very noticeable pumpkin-spice scent.

The fragrance is the biggest problem. Instead of smelling like a subtle autumn lotion, it can resemble a strongly scented seasonal candle.

The original taste-test reviewer was particularly put off by the intensity. For anyone sensitive to fragranced skincare, it’s an easy skip. Trader Joe’s regular hand creams are likely to be more versatile for everyday use.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.