Publix has dropped its highly anticipated limited-edition holiday ice cream collection for 2025, blending nostalgic classics with bold new twists. From cozy coffee-inspired scoops to indulgent dessert recreations, these flavors are available now in half-gallon and pint sizes while supplies last. We’ve compiled the full lineup below, complete with detailed descriptions and authentic user feedback from across Reddit, YouTube, and other sources. Whether you’re hosting a holiday gathering or treating yourself, these creamy delights are sure to bring some cheer!
Half-Gallon Flavors
Coffee Chai Latte Premium Ice Cream $7.29
White coffee flavored ice cream with cinnamon molasses cookie pieces and white chocolate flavored chai swirls. This new flavor captures the warmth of a spiced latte in every bite, perfect for chilly evenings.
- “Publix limited editions are usually great.” (Reddit user km101010, praising Publix’s seasonal offerings overall)
Deep Dish Apple Pie Premium Ice Cream $7.29
Apple flavored ice cream swirled with brown sugar-cinnamon sauce, pieces of real apple, and sugar-rolled pie crust. It’s like a slice of homemade apple pie, but frozen and scoopable.
- “?Deep Dish Apple Pie?” (Reddit user rocksandthings420, expressing excitement)
- “Given a 5 out of 5… ingredients mentioned include brown sugar, cinnamon sauce, pieces of real apple… good for apple pie lovers.” (YouTube reviewer, who called it “fire” and “so good”)
Eggnog Premium Ice Cream $7.29
Rich eggnog flavored ice cream with a kiss of nutmeg. A creamy, spiced classic that evokes holiday traditions.
- “I am impressed!!” (Reddit user Terrible_Sock_451, in the context of seasonal flavors like eggnog)
- “Given a 4.7 out of 5… captures all the qualities of eggnog and is creamy and flavorful… recommended for people who love eggnog.” (YouTube reviewer, who suggested making eggnog milkshakes)
Marshmallow, Candy Cane & Cookie Blast Premium Ice Cream $7.29
Marshmallow flavored ice cream with bits of candy cane and a chocolate cookie swirl. A fun, festive mix that’s sweet and crunchy.
- “Their holiday marshmallow cookie candy cane is my favorite.” (Reddit user km101010)
- “Publix’s new “Marshmallow, Candy Cane and Cookie Blast” ice cream = What Christmas tastes like.” (Reddit user in r/christmas)
- “You will be glad you did! Publix ice cream is probably my favorite store brand.” (Reddit user [deleted], encouraging others to try it)
Peppermint Stick Premium Ice Cream $7.29
Luscious vanilla ice cream with festive bits of peppermint candy. Refreshing and minty, ideal for peppermint lovers.
- “Peppermint stick is my all time favorite!!” (Reddit user Existing_Many9133)
- “Peppermint stick flies off the shelf.” (Reddit user Apprehensive_Mark_51, noting its popularity)
- “It comes back for Christmas and will be available with santas white christmas, eggnog and peppermint.” (Reddit user kenholler, confirming it’s a returning favorite)
Pumpkin Pie Premium Ice Cream $7.29
Pumpkin pie-flavored ice cream with swirls of whipped cream and buttery-flavored piecrust pieces. All the autumnal vibes in a tub.
- “One night last winter I got beat up all day at the deli and I only had like $8 in my account… so I ate an entire half gallon of pumpkin pie (best by far) for dinner and had no regrets ???.” (Reddit user Ultimate_Summerboy)
- “Pumpkin pie ?.” (Reddit user gaybacon96)
- “pumpkin pie ?.” (Reddit user cowboylikeria)
Rum Nut Bread Pudding Premium Ice Cream $7.29
Vanilla-rum raisin flavored ice cream with cinnamon crème flavored swirls, praline pecans, and blondie brownie pieces. A boozy, nutty take on a comforting dessert (new for 2025).
- “Publix limited editions are usually great.” (Reddit user km101010, on seasonal flavors in general)
Santa’s White Christmas Premium Ice Cream $7.29
The classic flavor of Barnie’s Santa’s White Christmas coffee delightfully mixed with cocoa espresso flakes. Coffee-forward with a holiday twist.
- “That and the Santa’s White Christmas are back. I can already feel the pounds coming on, but totally worth it.” (Reddit user Aeruhat)
- “Hell yeah, bringing back Santa’s White Christmas ??.” (Reddit user Vandorbelt)
- “The best one. Hands down.” (Reddit user No_Hyena8479)
Pint-Sized Flavors
Banana Nut Bread Premium Ice Cream $6.09
Banana bread flavored ice cream with walnut pieces and swirls of banana sauce. Moist banana bread vibes in frozen form.
- “Bananas Foster and New Orleans Caramel Praline have been found and tried by another redditor as well.” (Reddit user cancat918, implying positive trial for similar banana-based flavors)
Bourbon Eggnog Premium Ice Cream $6.09
Rich bourbon eggnog flavored ice cream with a kiss of nutmeg. A spiked version of the classic for adults.
- “Given a 4.7 out of 5… captures all the qualities of eggnog and is creamy and flavorful.” (YouTube reviewer on similar eggnog flavor, adaptable here)
Candy Bar Premium Ice Cream $6.09
Vanilla ice cream bursting with peanut butter cups, milk chocolate gems, baked chocolate truffles, pretzel bark pieces, and honey caramel swirls. A candy lover’s dream packed with mix-ins.
- “This is a taste test/review of Publix Ice Cream in three limited edition flavors including Candy Bar…” (YouTube video description, indicating it’s reviewed positively as part of the holiday lineup)
Chocolate Stout Pretzel Blitz Premium Ice Cream $6.09
Chocolate stout flavored ice cream with chocolate pretzel swirls, chocolate pecans, and peanut brittle pieces. Rich, beer-inspired chocolate with salty crunch.
- “This is a taste test/review of Publix Ice Cream in three limited edition flavors… Chocolate Stout Pretzel Blitz” (YouTube video description, highlighting it as a featured review)
Hot Honey Mascarpone Praline Premium Ice Cream $6.09
Mascarpone ice cream dotted with praline pecans and hot honey flavored ribbons. Creamy with a sweet-spicy kick.
- “This is a taste test/review of Publix Ice Cream in three limited edition flavors… Hot Honey Mascarpone Praline” (YouTube video description, part of the positive holiday reviews)
Raspberry Elegance Premium Ice Cream $6.09
White chocolate flavored ice cream with ribbons of raspberry sauce, dotted with white chocolatey raspberry flavored cups. Inspired by Publix’s popular Raspberry Elegance Cake (note: not an exact match).
- “Most limited edition flavors come back…” (Reddit user Treveli, on returning favorites like this elegant option)
