Publix shoppers continue to campaign for the return of beloved discontinued items—from classic bakery treats to one-of-a-kind deli favorites.
These products earned a loyal following for their flavor, quality, and place in family traditions, making their disappearance especially felt.
We’ve gathered 20 fan-favorite picks that spark the loudest calls for a comeback, with hopes they’ll reappear at the prices customers remember.
Meyer Lemon Cookies
- Bright, tangy lemon-flavored cookies from the bakery with a soft texture and citrus glaze; fans want them back for their refreshing summer vibe and unique flavor not matched by other brands.
Fruit Bars (Bakery)
- Chewy bars packed with real fruit like strawberry or blueberry, often topped with icing; shoppers miss them for easy snacks and nostalgic school lunch memories, with no comparable fresh alternative.
Macaroni Salad
- Creamy deli salad with elbow pasta, mayo, and veggies; fans crave its picnic-perfect taste and convenience, saying store-bought versions lack Publix’s fresh, homemade quality.
Potato Salad
- Classic Southern-style with mustard, eggs, and potatoes; beloved for potlucks and holidays, fans petition for its return due to the unique tangy recipe unmatched elsewhere.
Frozen Butter Peas (Publix Brand)
- Tender, buttery peas frozen for easy cooking; discontinued during COVID, fans want them back for Southern side dishes, citing superior taste over canned options.
Ba-Tampte Sour Pickles
- Tangy, garlicky kosher pickles in brine; shoppers miss their crisp snap and authentic deli flavor, with no equivalent in current stock.
Taco Chicken Dip
- Spicy, creamy dip with chicken, cheese, and taco seasoning; fans lament its loss for game days, saying it’s irreplaceable for parties and quick appetizers.
Sour Cream and Onion Popcorn
- Light, tangy popcorn with onion seasoning; discontinued fans want it back for movie nights, praising its addictive flavor over bagged alternatives.
Icebox Cheesecake Bars
- No-bake bars with graham crust and creamy filling; petitions highlight their convenience and rich taste, unmatched for easy desserts.
Hurricane Cakes
- Fun, storm-themed cakes with colorful icing; over 39,000 signatures on petitions for their return, as fans miss the humorous tradition during hurricane season.
Mango Lemonade
- Refreshing, tropical lemonade blend; fans want it back for its unique sweet-tart profile, a summer staple not replicated by other juices.
Carrot Cake Cookies
- Soft cookies with carrot cake spices and cream cheese filling; discontinued in 2024 but revived briefly—fans push for permanent return due to addictive flavor.
Publix Brand Salad Dressings (Various Flavors)
- Creamy or vinaigrette options like ranch or Italian; fans miss the affordable, fresh taste, with reformulations not satisfying loyal users.
Store Brand Deli Products (e.g., Specific Hams and Turkeys)
- Pre-sliced meats with unique seasonings; shoppers want them back for sandwiches, citing quality loss in the deli overhaul.
Publix Hummus
- Smooth, garlicky hummus from the dips section; discontinued in a product overhaul, fans crave its creamy texture over replacements.
Chocolate Bars (Discontinued Clearance)
- Assorted flavors like dark or milk chocolate; fans miss the variety for baking and snacking, with no similar affordable options.
Cake and Brownie Mixes
- Easy-bake mixes with rich flavors; discontinued varieties left fans searching for alternatives, praising Publix’s moist results.
Blueberry Pie (or Similar Bakery Item)
- Flaky pie with fresh blueberries; fans want it back for its homemade taste, a seasonal favorite now absent.
Strawberry Version (e.g., Strawberry Pie or Bars)
- Sweet strawberry-filled bakery item; discontinued alongside others, missed for fresh fruit balance in desserts.
Sweet Honey Bread
- Soft, honey-sweetened bread; fans nostalgically want it back for its unique sweetness in sandwiches or toast.
